Karity's dupe list had Inod as being a dupe for MAC's Soft Brown. It's close enough, but Soft Brown has a pinkish undertone compared to Inod, which appears orange next to Soft Brown. I've heard that Soft Brown is close to Mug Creme Brule--I've never swatched them both together because I don't have Creme Brule--but honestly, Inod is closer of a dupe to MUG's Frappe than it is to MAC's Soft Brown. It doesn't hurt to have all of them though, you can never have too many eyeshadows! From what I've heard, people pay $10 for MAC eyeshadows in the pan, but I pay $6 for them where I'm at (Louisiana), which isn't that far away in price compared to Karity's (which is $4.50 for me) and Mugs's single eyeshadows (also $6), so the price difference wasn't what drew me to want to try Karity's shadows. I found out about Karity through their dupe list, and I thought, if any brand compares their colors to another brand like MAC, they must feel very confident about their product. And they should, because the quality of their shadows are five-star!
